History of Sicklerville United Methodist Church
and the Town of Sicklerville, New Jersey

                                                                                

  • The name "Sicklerville" was from derived from John Sickler who settled in the locality at an early period (date unknown), rearing three sons who improved the farms at this point in time. Other early settlers were John, Jacob and George Ware (from which the area was sometimes referred to as "Waretown").
  • Its railroad station was "Sicklertown".
  • The first Post Office for "Sicklerville" was established in 1874. Paul H. Sickler was appointed Postmaster, keeping office in his store (which was opened in 1865).
  • In 1886, there were only ten residences in "Sicklerville".
  • Sicklerville is one of the small communities comprising Winslow Township. Other communities include Albion, Ancora, Atco, Blue Anchor, Braddock, Cedar Brook, Elm, Florance, Ivy Stone, Penbryn, Rosedale, Tansboro, West Atco, Waterford Works, and Winslow.
  • The Township of Winslow was created by an act of the Senate and General Assembly of the State of New Jersey on March 8, 1845. Winslow Township was created from a part of Gloucester Township. Today, Winslow Township covers 57.4 square miles.
  • The first town meeting was held at the Blue Anchor Inn (proprietor: Josiah Albertson) in Blue Anchor on the second Wednesday of March in the same year. The Blue Anchor Inn was located on Route 73 in the center of the duel highway in the vicinity of St. Lucy's Church.
  • The next township meeting was held at the Red Lion Inn (Proprietor: William Middleton of Clementon)
  • In 1859-64, William K. Sickler was assessor.
  • In 1883-86, Jacob Sickler was named collector.


"The Sicklerville Methodist Episcopal Church"

(from Prowell's History of Camden County - published in 1886)

The first Methodist meetings in this locality were held in private houses and in the school house, most of the preaching done by John Sickler, a local preacher. The members were his sons -- Christopher, John and William and their families -- and Joseph Jones. In 1837, William Sickler set aside an acre of land for church purposes, and soon after the neighbors united in building a small farm house thereon. Here, schools were kept during the week and religious meetings on the Sabbath -- the attendants coming from many miles

Some time after, Sickler donated an additional acre of land to establish a cemetery [located on Church Street, Sicklerville], deeding the entire trust of John Sickler, John Bartin, Christopher Sickler and Thomas Lashley. The building was used until 1859, when the small church was erected in its stead. [The small church still stands today -- and is located on Church Road, Sicklerville and owned by the Sicklerville United Methodist Church. (See below article)]

It is a neat frame structure, thirty-five by forty-five feet, which has been made attractive by recent improvements. In 1886, William Andrew, William Shreeve, S.W. Sickler and Paul H. Sickler were named as trustees of the church. Paul H. Sickler has been a local preacher for the past twenty years. In 1886, the membership of the church was small, the entire number not exceeding twenty-five, and the pastoral service was in connection with churches in Gloucester County, but for many years it was joined to Tansboro in forming a charge. In 1886, there was a Sunday School of sixty members and Sears W. Sickler was it superintendent. It was organized soon after the class was formed by Paul H. and John J. Sickler.

 

"Sicklerville United Methodist Church"

(taken from Steps of Faith Newsletter, Jan. 2002)

The early history of this Church is like many previous souls "lost for the want of faithful ministers."

The best that can be determined, a group of people who wished to worship God, gathered for worship on a site which is now the old cemetery located on Church Street. When death came to the community, this place was used for the burial.

Realizing that there would be a need for a burial ground, the trustees -- William T. Sickler, Christopher Sickler, Sr., Sears W. Sickler, William Sickler, Christopher Downs, Jacob M. Jennings, and John I. Sickler, purchased .6 acre of ground from William Sickler for $50.00 on February 9, 1859.

Records indicate that Tansboro, Atco and Sicklertown churches were on the same Circuit around 1872. This remained until 1904 when the circuit became Tansboro and Sicklertown.

This action left a need for a parsonage. A half-acre of ground was given to the trustes, Christopher Cheesman, James M. Johnson, Sr., Sears W. Sickler, Samuel J. Forman and John Johnson by Frederick Clark. A parsonage was erected for the use of the minister of the church. This parsonage was occupied until 1928, at which time the trustees were authorized to sell the parsonage as the ministers were now living in Tansboro. The parsonage was finally sold and torn down. The ground was used for an additional burial ground.

In 1939, due to merger, the Circuit included New Brooklyn. This remained until 1942 when Atco and Sicklerville were placed on the same Circuit.

The first wedding on record ever performed in the church took place on October 4, 1947 uniting John Thornton and Alice McClintock in Matrimony.

In 1953, there became a need for the erection of a building where Sunday School classes and fellowship meetings could be held. On March 11, 1953, the ground was broken for the present Church school. Most of the work was done by the men of the church -- under the leadership of William Albertson, a local contractor and trustee of the church. The cost was $5,218.38.

Thus, we can see through hardships and prosperity, that God has continued to bless us here in Sicklerville.

In 1959, the Board of Trustee members serving the church included Richard R. Thornton, President; Joseph Andrew, Howard Andrew, Albert E. Johnson, W. Jacob Robinson, Jack Thornton, Herman G. Bussom and William K. Albertson.

 

"The New Church is Now, But the Old is Their Roots"

 Reprinted from the Glouc. Co. Times, [date _______] - written by Bob Shryock of the Gloucester County Times, Woodbury, NJ

On one side of Williamstown-New Freedom and Church Roads in Winslow Township, parishioners worship in a new sanctuary and study the Bible in the new educational wing of Sicklerville Methodist Church.

Meanwhile, on the opposite side of the road, work is about to begin to restore the original 131-year-old church building which sustained $100,000 in damages during a fire in April.

It is one of the area's oldest churches and, quite clearly, its members have not lost their touch with history. One option after the fire was to tear down the heavily damaged church and direct the insurance money to expenses incurred by the additions to the new church. But no one took that possibility seriously for very long.

"We are what we are today because of that (old) church," says Rev. Jerry Ruff, who has been pastor of Sicklerville Methodist for seven years. "We're a very close church. Sicklerville is a very fast-growing, transient area and there are a lot of established communities around. We have some young people in our church who have no roots in the area. But they still have a sense of historical perspective that that church stands for who we are."

In 1937, William Sickler, one of the descendants of the family which started what first was called Sicklertown, set aside one acre of land for a new church at a cost of $50. Parishioners 21 years later began meeting in their homes and at the schoolhouse at Church and Turnersville Roads to draw up the plans for the new Sicklerville Methodist Episcopal Church.

And the Sickler name was, needless to say, prominent in the organizational efforts of the church.

The first pastor was John Sickler.

The charter trustees included William T. Sickler, William Sickler, and Christopher Sickler, Sr.

After construction was completed in 1859, the new church served two important purposes. Religious services and church school, obviously, were held there on Sundays. And during the week the church was used as the town's elementary school.

During the middle of the 19th Century, Sicklerville Methodist Episcopal was part of the Methodist circuit which included churches in Tansboro and Atco.

In 1928, a parsonage was built next to the church. On Oct. 4, 1947 the church held its first wedding, although Pastor Ruff has no information to explain why it took 88 years to happen. In 1968, "Episcopal" was dropped from the name of the church.

The church celebrated its 100th anniversary and remained a relatively small congregation with fewer than 100 members until a clear growth pattern was established in the mid-1970s. And in 1976, the church decided to build a new church on four acres directly across the street from the old one, which no longer could accommodate the increasing membership.

"Some of the oldtimers didn't want to move because they'd grown up in that church," Pastor Ruff says, "but they did."

The old church was able to hold only about 50 people. With its new sanctuary, the new one sits 375. The membership is now over 300 and climbing. Pastor Ruff says the average Sunday worship attendance is 330.

Prior to the fire, the original church was being used as an adult Sunday School class as well as for weddings and concerts. It also was being rented to other small congregations as a beginning church.

But the April fire was devastating. Although the structure withstood the blaze, interior damage was severe -- to the tune of $100,000. For example, of the six original stained glass windows, four did not survive the fire. Most of the damage was covered by insurance although the foundation will have to be rebuilt at the expense of the church.

The church's original wooden plate - "M.E. Church 1859" - did survive and stands as a monument to its future.

Pastor Ruff, with his seven years, is the minister with the longest tenure serving Sicklerville Methodist in its 131 years. He laughs and says he plans to be there "for seven more."

"We're about ready to start reconstruction and we're hopeful that it will be finished by Christmas," he says. "When it's done, we'll continue to not only use it for our purposes but to lease it as well."

"The church is a constant reminder of where we came from. I'm very thrilled that so many of our members want to see it restored."

"Rules Of The M.E. Church"

(adopted March 13, 1876)

  • 1st. Seats free. The first person in the seat, will move back, or step out, to let the other pass in.
  • 2d. No person allowed to deface in any way, the seats or wall of the House, with pencil, knife or the feet.
  • 3d. No person allowed to stand in the vestibule, during hours of service.
  • 4th. No running out during the hours of service, except in cases of necessity.
  • 5th. No whispering or laughing allowed during the hours of service.
  • 6th. The use of tobacco strictly prohibited in every part of the House.
    7th. These Rules will be enforced by the authority of the Trustees.

     

"Time in a Bottle"

(reprinted from ______________)

Workers find historic jar in church wall

Reprinted from the Glouc. Co. Times, [date _______] - written by Tery Schneider of the Gloucester County Times, Woodbury, NJ

WINSLOW TWP. - A 131-year-old piece of Williamstown's history was discovered unexpectedly Thursday when workers found a fruit jar embedded in the wall of the Sicklerville United Methodist Church.

"I guess it was their version of our time capsule," said Gail Henry.

Encased in the light green jar were coins dating back to 1841, a newspaper and hand-printed minutes of what appeared to be some kind of annual conference that was held at the Methodist Church.

There was a mention of the upcoming curriculum for the Sunday school and clerical appointments in the paper dated before 1859, Henry said.

But what was most remarkable about the discovery of the Williamstown jar and its contents was that if it wasn't for a fire at the church this year, it might have never been found.

The fire damaged the church's already weakening foundation, Henry said. The church had to be lifted up and new foundation poured.

In preparing for the new foundation, workers found the glass jar perched inside one of the church's cornerstones where it had been housed since the church was built in 1859.

Henry said none of the congregation members knew the glass jar was embedded in the church walls.
   

As workers from the William E. Russell and Sons Building Moving Engineers Co. of Mullica Hill were digging on Thursday, they noticed something sparkling in the sunlight. They stopped their work and called Rev. Jerry Ruff, the church's pastor, over to the site.

Ruff examined the glass jar and found that it had been made in Williamstown by the "Bodine Brothers".

The markings on the 7-inch bottle clearly reads that the jar was made in Williamstown and that the company had a "patented glass lid on the air-tight fruit jar."

What was found inside the jar appeared to be a little more weathered than the jar, Henry said.

She said that they were worried about opening the newspaper that was dated 1859 because of its age. All that can be ascertained from the paper is its date and that it contained an article about Methodists. The coins that were found in the bottle also interested Henry.

She said there was a 1841 United States penny that was bigger than a quarter and a thin coin that bore the name of the Bodine Brothers' store.

Henry said she was going to call the local historical society to see what to do with the "extremely fragile" remnants of time long gone.

She said she didn't know how to care for the historic treasurers because "now everything we have, we stick in plastic."